
What was former quant trader Richard Ho’s thinking when he copied his former employer Headlands Technologies‘ secret sauce for algorithmic trading? The answer to the question will determine Ho’s fate in his criminal case now being tried by the U.S. Attorney’s Office for the Southern District of New York.
Ho’s defense team at the law firm of Skadden, Arps, Slate, Meager & Flom, has conceded that he copied some of HT’s source code, but denies he either used it or intended to use it. The prosecution led by Assistant U.S. Attorneys Rushmi Bhaskaran and Ni Quan, aims to prove otherwise. Ho, otherwise known as Cheuk Fung Richard Ho, has pleaded not guilty to charges that he stole or attempted to steal trade secrets from Headlands Technologies (HT), a private quantitative proprietary trading firm in Chicago, in 2021 to launch his own firm One R2 Squared (ORS). He also denied the separate charge of wire fraud by convincing HT rival Tower Research Capital (TRC) into investing US$15 million into ORS to develop automated trading strategies.
Ho and two of his former colleagues at HT, Wen Jia Liu and Hai Son Le who joined him at ORS, allegedly used HT’s formulas on TRC’s trading platform to harm HT by front-running Headlands trades on the Chicago Mercantile Exchange, Intercontinental Exchange, and other markets. The indictment against Ho identified “Atoms” as the building blocks of HT’s source code and “Alphas” as predictive formulas. The prosecutors claimed that HT spent more than US$1 billion to develop its source code.
If found guilty of theft or attempted theft of trade secrets, Ho could face up to 10 years in prison. If found guilty of wire fraud, he could receive up to 20 years in prison. While the prosecutors in Ho’s criminal case have described TRG as Ho’s victim, HT is pursuing a separate civil case against TRC allegedly helping Ho to perpetuate his crime. HT claimed that TRG, a privately-held high-frequency trading firm in New York, knew or should have known that Ho’s formulas were derived from HT. The civil case has made its way into the CME’s arbitration process. (Members of the CME are requied to take any disputes into arbitration). The CME declined to provide FinOps Report with any update while HT and TRC did not respond to e-mails seeking comment.
The criminal case against Ho started in January 2025, and the trial in New York began in early November 2026 after U.S. District Judge Jeannette Vargas denied Ho’s efforts to have the charges dismissed on the grounds that the prosecution did not supply a sufficient number of files to the defense as evidence of possible wrongdoing. Ho asserted that by cherry-picking the prosecution was violating his constitutional rights to a fair trial. A separate civil case filed by HT against Ho in Chicago for breach of contract and misappropriation of data is pending. FinOps Report could not verify what happened to Wen Jia Liu and Hai-Son Le, Ho’s colleagues at HT who joined him at ORS. Liu was listed by HT as a witness for HT in its civil case against Ho, while Le was listed as a defendant.
As a type of intellectual property, trade secrets are a step above confidential data. The criteria for what can be protected under trade secrets laws is broader than what can be protected under patent law. Unlike patents which can expire in twenty years, trade secrets have no expiration date. Algorithmic trading formulas are one type of financial trade secret; others include database designs, blueprints of inventions, and crypto-related codes.
The definition of a trade secret is based on federal and individual state laws following the Uniform Trade Secrets Act. (New York is an exception in that it relies on case law). To receive legal protection, the owner of a trade secret must take “reasonable measures” to make the information secret and prove the data derives economic value from not being publicly known.
Public information on Ho’s trial, which started in early November in New York City, is limited because most of the testimony has been heard behind closed doors due to US District Judge Jeannette Vargas’ concerns about possible leakage of trade secrets. However, based on what has been been reported in some media outlets, Ho’s defense conceded that he did copy at least some of his former employer’s formulas but that doesn’t prove his guilt. He never used or planned to use those formulas in the algorithms he developed at ORS.
To win the case for trade secrets theft, the prosecution must prove that Ho knew the copied information he took with him was a trade secret, that he knew he was not authorized to copy it, that he intended to convert the data for his economic benefit or anyone else other than HT, and that he knew his action would injure HT. “The fact that Ho’s defense acknowledged that he copied some of HT’s data seemingly establishes the first prong of the prosecution’s case [for trade secrets theft] and makes it a lot easier to prove,” explained Gregory Ewing, a partner in the law firm of Spencer Fane in Washington, D.C.
The prosecution doesn’t have to show that HT lost any money because of Ho’s actions. Anyone who knowingly copies trade secrets to benefit a competing business can be found guilty of theft, even if the plan never succeeds. Based on media reports Lena Lowenstine, a government expert witness, testified at Ho’s pre-trial hearing that based on the similarities between HT and ORT’s formulas using a data sample provided to the prosecution by HT, the formulas at ORS were developed entirely from HT; they could not have been independently produced by Ho. According to Lowenstine, who works for the Federal Bureau of Investigation as a software analyst, there were matching structures and repeated identical programming choices in numerous instances. “It’s like two textbooks with the same chapters, same sections, and the sentences are saying the same thing; it’s one to one,” she reportedly said. Ho’s defense, in turn, tried to discredit Lowenstine by showing she had no experience in high frequency trading.
It could not be determined whether the defense’s expert rebuttal witness Mark Hendricks, director of the financial mathematics program at the University of Chicago, was allowed to testify during Ho’s trial, During a pre-trial hearing he had difficulty substantiating his claim that HT’s code existed at other trading firms because he declined to provide any specific examples. Hendricks claimed he had signed nondisclosure or confidentiality agreements. Over the objection of Ho’s defense, Judge Vargas allowed prosecutors to contact Hendricks’ prior employers to test the validity of Hendricks’ expertise. Ho’s defense was worried that the prosecution’s investigation would scare Hendricks into not testifying for the defense.
Regardless of how Ho got a hold of HT’s formulas, the question remains as to whether they were actually used in ORS’ trading strategies? There would be no case if they weren’t. The fact they might have been copied does not prove they were used. Ho’s defense could argue that any copied formulas existed in a database, not in any executed trades. The prosecution would need to match up the copied code with the code used by Ho’s trading system to debunk the defense’s possible theory they were just meant to be stored.
If the prosecution could show that Ho actually deployed HT’s formulas, where would that leave the defense? In a far weaker position. Even if the burden of proof is on the prosecution to prove that the material Ho copied constituted trade secrets, the defense would be forced as a last ditch effort to poke holes in that theory as it developed during the trial. The Department of Justice has indicated that “publicly known” data is a potential defense against trade secrets theft and the defense could argue that elements of HT’s data were public. It could not be determined whether Casey Worthington, a partner and co-head of research at HT, has testified for the prosecution about HT’s proprietary formulas meeting the criteria for trade secrets. (The defense had objected to the last-minute notice of the prosecution’s witnesses).
The defense could try to defuse the prosecution’s claim that Ho had the intent to benefit from copying HT’s formulas into ORS. However, given the timeline of Ho’s actions that will be hard to do. Ho registered the domain name of One R Squared on March 15, 2021 as OneRSq.com and incorporated his new firm in Delaware on May 6, 2021. He resigned from HT on July 6, 2021 and became a consultant to TRC one month later. According to the prosecution, Ho told his colleagues at ORS in the spring of 2023 to delete any communications with him about the formulas used and the source code itself, but they did not follow his instructions. (The defense denies the directive was given). “The prosecution could also show that Ho intended to benefit from using HT’s formulas by looking into any communications, such as e-mails Ho exchanged with, or presentations Ho gave to potential clients using the formulas as a pitch,” explained Spencer Fane’s Ewing who heads up his law firm’s data privacy and cybersecurity practice. (As a condition of his release on bail, Ho agreed that ORS would not trade in any financial products while his criminal case remained pending).
Even if the prosecution fails to win its case against Ho for trade secrets theft it could still win the case for wire fraud because of the lower burden of proof. Wire fraud only requires evidence that Ho intentionally lied about the code he used at ORS and TRC based its decision to invest in ORS on that lie. The prosecution does not have to prove the code was a trade secret. The deception could be as simple as Ho telling TRC that the code he created at ORS was independently developed and not copied from HT. The latest media reports about the case indicated that prosecutors had asked Judge Vargas to prevent the defense from using TRC’s response to learning of allegations against Ho in 2023 as evidence Ho had not misled TRC. Therefore, no fraud occurred. There was no public updated news as to how Judge Vargas ruled in the matter.
Regardless of how Ho fares in his criminal trial, two things are certain. Concerned about the reputational risk of showing they didn’t do enough to protect their trade secrets, financial firms will likely try to bolster their access and security measures. Ho’s indictment showed that Ho was able to download the information from HT onto his own computer without any alarms going off to HT’s security or compliance team until it was too late. Employees involved in trading or designing trading formulas will also need to be far more wary of copying any information marked as confidential even if they don’t think it is a trade secret.
Among the publications which have covered Richard Ho’s trial and were used by FinOps Report in the preparation of this article are Bloomberg, Financial Crime Matters, Hoodline, Inner City Press, and Matthew Russell Lee’s newsletter Patreon Book Substack. Among those, Inner City Press offered the most details.
Chris Kentouris
KentourisC@gmail.com
917-510-3226
Algorithms# BrokerageOperations# CME# ChicagoMercantileExchange# FBI# FinancialOperations# FinOps# HeadlandsTechnologies# IntellectualProperty# ICE# IntercontinentalExchange# LegalProtection# QuantTrading# RichardHo# SkaddenArps# TowerResearchCapital# TradeSecrets# TradeSecretsTheft#
Leave a Comment
You must be logged in to post a comment.